Presidential Powers and the Evolution of Polycentric Governance Systems

A lot of media attention is paid to legislative gridlock on Capitol Hill. At the same time, public policy in the United States also moves beneath the surface, flowing through a complex network of bureaucratic agencies, courts, related actors and decision-making processes at varying levels of government. Policy scholars, Mark Lubell and Jennifer Victor, refer to this as polycentric governance. They further speak to how presidential administrations work through this network to reshape administrative and intergovernmental structures, as well as imprint their political preferences on the direction of public policy.

In their perspective piece, “Presidential Powers and the Evolution of Polycentric Governance Systems”, Drs. Lubell and Victor discuss how presidential administrations use executive actions to alter, sometimes drastically, this domain to pursue their political agendas. By comparing the environmental policies of Presidents Joe Biden and Donald Trump (2nd Term), the authors discuss how presidents exert policy influence through adjusting administrative structures and policies.

How Have Recent Presidential Administrations Reshaped Polycentric Governance

The authors highlight four ways that recent presidential administrations have actively reshaped the arena of polycentric governance in environmental policy:

  • Creating and Eliminating Forums: Presidents can use executive orders (EOs) to structurally create policy forums or spaces to accelerate their policy ambitions or eliminate those same forums to alter policymaking in a different direction.
  • Changing Forum Rules: In cases where presidents are unable to directly eliminate a policy forum as a result of legal protections, they can influence existing forums by altering the institutional rules, jurisdictional boundaries, or the blend of participating actors involved.
  • Shifting Forum Resources: Because policy forums require material resources such as funding and staffing, presidents can shift forum resources by defunding or reducing agency personnel.
  • Centralization: Given how fragmented and decentralized polycentric systems are, presidents can mandate whole-of-government approaches (i.e., centralized bodies) to overcome the independent specialization of some federal agencies and align them under a single executive policy agenda.

Why It Matters

A notable way that presidents can shape the policy process is through structural engineering of polycentric institutions. When executives systematically create, alter, or eliminate established policy forums and networks, they are effectively reshaping administrative and legal boundaries. While many scholars analyze polycentric governance as a mechanism for policy collaboration, it may also offer a lens through which to understand the varied ways that specific actors shape different aspects of the policy process.

Read the original article in Policy Studies Journal:

Lubell, Mark, and Jennifer Victor. 2026. Presidential Powers and the Evolution of Polycentric Governance Systems. Policy Studies Journal, 54(1), e70069: https://doi.org/10.1111/psj.70069.

About the Article’s Author(s)

Mark Lubell is a Professor at the Department of Environmental Science and Policy at the University of California, Davis. He also serves as the Director of the Center for Environmental Policy and Behavior at UC Davis. His research focuses on human behavior and the role of governance institutions in solving collective action problems and facilitating cooperation.

Jennifer Victor is an Associate Professor of Political Science at George Mason University’s Schar School Policy and Government. Her research focuses on the U.S. Congress, legislative organization and behavior, social network methods, political parties, campaign finance, organized interest groups, and lobbying.

Leave a Reply